Garage Sale Mystery Series – All of the Movies in Order

This is a list of the chapters in the popular Hallmark series Garage Sale Mystery. A US-Canadian mystery film series starring Lori Loughlin as Jennifer Shannon.

Inspired in some part by Agatha Christie’s stories. I’ve included all of the episodes in the series, listed in order of release. Plus details of where to watch or stream online for UK and US on Amazon Prime or Apple TV+.

For more top Hallmark Movies & Mysteries series lists and more, see my posts listed below.

Garage Sale Mystery Series

Main/Recurring Cast: Lori Loughlin as Jennifer Shannon. Steve Bacic as Jason Shannon. Sarah Strange as Danielle “Dani”. Eva Bourne as Hannah Shannon. Connor Stanhope as Logan Shannon. Kevin O’Grady as Detective Frank Lynwood.

These made for TV mystery movies each first aired on national TV channels such as: the Hallmark Movies & Mysteries Channel (US), Bravo (Canada), Channel 5 (UK) and eMovies HD (South Africa). After airing on TV, they are then are available to watch on DVD (including a Complete Mystery Collection DVD box set with all of the available 16 movies!) They’re also available to stream online with services like Amazon Prime Video, see below for UK and US Amazon links for each episode.

1. Garage Sale Mystery

Released: 2013 | IMDb rating: 6.8 (1.6K).

Plot: Jen hunts at garage sales. At one she makes a lunch date with Kate. She finds her dead in her house. The police says accident. Jen thinks murder related to her break-ins after garage sales theory. [Source: Amazon]

For more details: Garage Sale Mysteries Episodes: Pilot (2013).

*All 16 Garage Sale Mysteries Episodes available as a DVD box set from UK Amazon and US Amazon. Also available to watch online free with US Amazon and Hallmark Movies Now. Also stream on Apple TV+.

2. All That Glitters

Released: 2014 | IMDb rating: 6.9 (1170).

Plot: The owner of a storage place is found by Jen’s deduction, murdered. Jen saw an upset ex customer there earlier and the owner mentioned divorce. Is the break-in at Jen and Dani’s store related? Dani meets a new guy. [Source: Amazon]

For more details: Garage Sale Mysteries Episode 2: All that Glitters (2014).

*All 16 Garage Sale Mysteries Episodes available as a DVD box set from UK Amazon and US Amazon. Or stream Garage Sale Mysteries 2: All That Glitters free online with US Amazon and Hallmark Movies Now. Also stream on Apple TV+.

3. The Deadly Room

Released: 2015 | IMDb rating: 6.9 (1070).

Plot: Jennifer uses her intuitive skills to investigate her friend’s death in a multimillion-dollar home with a dark history. [Source: Amazon]

For more details: Garage Sale Mysteries Episode 3 (2015) The Deadly Room.

*All 16 Garage Sale Mysteries Episodes available as a DVD box set from UK Amazon and US Amazon. Or stream Garage Sale Mysteries 3: The Deadly Room free online with US Amazon and Hallmark Movies Now. Also stream on Apple TV+.

4. The Wedding Dress

Released: 2015 | IMDb rating: 6.9 (1035).

Plot: The owner of an antique store comes across a wedding dress with a mysterious past and vows to solve the mystery of the missing groom. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

5. Guilty Until Proven Innocent

Released: 2016 | IMDb rating: 6.9 (937).

Plot: Antiques guru Jennifer Shannon (Lori Loughlin) investigates a murder after an old college friend becomes the prime suspect. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

6. The Novel Murders

Released: 2016 | IMDb rating: 7.0 (961).

Plot: Antiques expert Jennifer Shannon thinks two clues found at the scene of a murder are really clues from a mystery novel. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

7. The Art or Murder

Released: 2017 | IMDb rating: 6.7 (929).

Plot: While setting up a charity garage sale, Jennifer Shannon discovers a body in the attic of a nearby home. Using her eye for detail, as well as her experience with antiques and murder, Jennifer puts together clues that help catch a killer. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

8. The Beach Murder

Released: 2013 | IMDb rating: 6.8 (731).

Plot: Jen helps a widow who suspects foul play when her husband, an avid surfer and swimmer, is found dead on an isolated beach, the victim of an alleged drowning. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

9. Murder By Text

Released: 2017 | IMDb rating: 6.7 (716).

Plot: A bass player is found dead before a planned tour with a big country singer. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

10. Murder Most Medieval

Released: 2017 | IMDb rating: 6.8 (744).

Plot: Jen finds the body of a local college history professor hidden in a suit of armor she purchased. After the professor’s teaching assistant becomes the next victim, Jennifer finds herself caught in a killer’s web of dangerous lies. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

11. A Case of Murder

Released: 2017 | IMDb rating: 6.9 (709).

Plot: After buying an old reel-to-reel recorder at a garage sale, Jen discovers that it includes the sound of a man pleading for his life. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

12. The Pandora’s Box Murders

Released: 2018 | IMDb rating: 6.9 (600).

Plot: The daughter-in-law of a prestigious family enlists Jennifer’s help with a mysterious puzzle box that her mother-in-law left behind. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

13. The Mask Murder

Released: 2018 | IMDb rating: 6.9 (576).

Plot: Amateur detective Jen finds a young woman’s body in a storage locker after auction buying the contents of another for her store. Jen just can’t stay out of the investigation while the rest of the family is busy building homeless housing. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

14. Picture a Murder

Released: 2018 | IMDb rating: 7.0 (552).

Plot: Jennifer discovers an antique camera at the estate of a photography enthusiast. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

15. Murder in D Minor

Released: 2018 | IMDb rating: 7.0 (551).

Plot: Jennifer wins the bid on a vintage self-playing piano at an estate auction. The piano was owned by the late Karl Dietz and Jennifer discovers that this wealthy philanthropist has a dark history. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Prime Video | Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

16. Search & Seized

Released: 2019 | IMDb rating: 6.6 (118).

Plot: ‘Searched & Seized’ finds Jenn’s friend Miles running a police auction that features items seized in a money counterfeiting operation. When Miles turns up dead, Jen suspects he may have gotten involved with criminals to solve his debt problems. [Source: Amazon]

*Watch on UK Amazon: Complete 16 Film Collection DVD Box Set. Or on US Amazon: Complete 16 Movie Collection DVD Box Set. Also stream on Apple TV+.

17. Three Little Murders

Released: Garage Sale Mystery Three Little Murders was supposed to be the 17th episode in the series and filming had started on this chapter. But, as yet no further details of the movie including a release date, has been announced. And given that the main star is no longer working with Hallmark it is possible that this last episode will not be aired 🙁 But if there are new details, I’ll update it here!

Garage Sale Mystery: The Complete 16 Film Collection

UK Release: 2020.

Description: Jennifer Shannon has a gift for finding rare treasures hidden in garage sales that she can resell at her consignment store, Rags to Riches…

But her keen eye for finding valuables also gets her involved in the criminal investigations that happen at the very second-hand sales she frequents.

For the first time this special collection presents all 16 thrilling TV movies from one of the longest running Hallmark Movies & Mysteries Channel series! [Source: Amazon]

*Garage Sale Mystery – The Complete 16 Film Collection available on DVD from UK Amazon and US Amazon.

Watch Hallmark Mystery Movies Online Free

• Haunted Harmony Mysteries: Murder in G Major – New Hallmark Series 2023.
• Cut, Color, Murder – Hallmark Movie (2022) Now on Prime.
• Watch Ruby Herring Mysteries Episodes in Order Online.
• Watch The Gourmet Detective Mysteries in Order Free Online.
• Aurora Teagarden Movies in Order and Complete DVD Collection.
• Curious Caterer Mysteries Movies in Order.
• Hannah Swensen Mysteries Movies in Order (aka Murder She Baked).
• Picture Perfect Mysteries Hallmark Movies.

Check out my latest Top Cozy Mystery TV & Movies – News and Reviews.

You might also like: Aurora Teagarden Book Series in Order by Charlaine Harris and Hannah Swensen Mysteries in Order including New Books.

More Top Stuff for Mystery Fans!

• 10 Best Crime Dramas, Mysteries and Thrillers on Apple TV+.
• Top 10 True Crime Documentaries on Discovery+.
• 10 New British Cosy Mystery TV Dramas for 2024.
• Best Comedy Mystery Podcasts – New for 2021.
• Top 5 New Audiobook Thrillers – Feb’ 2024.
• 10 Top Free Detective Games to Play Online.
• 10 Free to Play Sherlock Games Online.

Don’t forget to check out my latest: Crime Dramas and Mystery TV Shows – News & Reviews.

*The above article may contain affiliate links, which help support this blog.

Follow on Facebook. Or subscribe to get the latest posts by email: